I figured out a water creature!!!! The Watcher at the West Gate of Moria! Remember he was the Watcher in the water and he pulled one of the Hobbits in the water. He made them run into the Mines of Moria because he was pretty strong. I think it had 13 or 14 arms. It was like a Kraken. Except I think he was evil.
-- Edited by Olorin on Thursday 6th of May 2010 06:06:19 PM