In a dule who would win Gandalf the Grey or Thorin Oakenshield. Here are the rules. No magic no tricks no one can interfear with their fight. Who would win Gandalf with Glamdring or Thorin with Orcrist both Elven sword from the Elder Days made in Gondolin for High-elven Kings. Don't forget to say why you picked your fighter.
P.S. By the way Thorin Oakenshield is a great and Honorable Dwarve from the book the Hobbit, and is a great fighter.
P.P.S. This is a sword dule so think hard on this and don't jump to conclutions!
I think Thorin because he is probably a more skilled swords man. As well as he is probably stronger and faster then old Gandalf. it does not matter if Gandalf is a maiar. he is pretty much just a man when it comes down to physical ability. Maybe Gandalf could come up with a tactical kinda of way to win but I still think thorin would in a way, well.... Own him!
