Arda

Well I would normaly say legolas, but for those of you say it is Legolas you are wrong in my eyes. I know that they are exsact equals! They are just compleatly equal strengths you don't see that often but they are equal. If you say Gimli because in the book at the siege of helms deep gimli got 42 kills and legolas got 41 kills so people say that Gimli is better. But over everything the are equals! So I am not voting.

So some people are better at other things but Gimli can do a lot of things that Legolas cant.

Same here, he would kill the enemy a lot faster. But Gimli would still get the job done.

Legolas is an Elf. His reaction time is faster. They may both get the job done but Legolas will get it done faster. Thus he is a greater warrior. In my opinion at least. I am still looking for compelling evidence to prove me wrong.

Well Gimli has more stamina and could last longer in a fight!

Acualy Legolas. I was reading in the lord of the rings book and it says Legolas has the most stamina of all the Fellowship. So Legolas would last longer. But remember Gimli won the fight at Helms deep beat legolas by 1 point. That means at that time Gimli was the better fighter.

Hey at that one battle he was better. Maybe at anouther Legolas was better. He killed more guys even if it was just once. But they are as I said both equals.