Arda

it said so in the book

have you ever noticed that on tolkiens books he has a special mark and I recently noticed that it has a "j" two "r"s and a "t"

ussaly on the side or back of the books

-- Edited by sir cody on Sunday 4th of July 2010 08:31:03 PM

Very interesting... It seems like there would be alot of barren areas in Arda then.

Why not?

At first it was not leting me post, now it is lol. And probably somthing about Hobbit culture I am sure of.

Lol, that is highly unlikely...

Because the SIlmarillion dose not exest in the world of Middle-earth silly. You know that.

Yes!!! Lol jk. Well he was only reading that book in the movie and not in the book. So with Petter Jackson's humor, he probably was reading the Silamrillion or the Lord of the Rinngs, haha!

yes, and hopfuly it comes out soon!

That is what they say anyways lol.

Only time will tell though.

Agreed. So anyways, lets pick somthing new to talk about. Got any ideas Illuvatar?

well back to what I was saying about the silmarilion why dosen't exsist in arda that's like saying the bible dosen't exsist

Ya and if it was written down and recorded then a Hobbit would not be reading it, I am sure of that. Unless that book was in the hored of Smaug and Smaug got it from an elve who he killed and horded everything he had, and that elve was recording the history down of the Waro f Jewles. And then Bilbo found it and then he gave it to frodo??????????????? Lol no jk. That is not posable because it makes a compleat list of what bilbo brought back from the Hord of Smaug the Golden and he did not bring back any books, not one.

Well sorta. In the hobbit it says he came back with gold and jewles.

He would have mentioned it in his books. This could not have happend.

-- Edited by Olorin on Monday 19th of July 2010 07:58:48 AM

thanks for supporting me iluvatar

-- Edited by Iluvatar on Tuesday 20th of July 2010 06:58:49 PM

What and where is Utumno?

It could not have happend in the movie people. in the book maybe. Do not use my theory agenst me!!!!!! That is insulting.

You guys are saying that it is posable for Smaug to have had it. I said that first. You guys are treating it as if you came up with it, when you didn't. And if could not have happened in the movie. But in the real story of Arda yes.

No I said it was not will bilbo that it was mentioned. I did not say that it was not in his cave.

Yes, I said he did not bring back any books. But the word tresure, could mean anything, including a book. I did not say it was not in his cave. And if that book exsisted the elves men or dwarves would have takin it. Not a hobbit. You know that.

Ya it could have happend, but I think the elves would have got a hand on it befor anyone els like a hobbit did. He had more to wory about then a book at that time.